Should Software ever be Re-Written?

Home » Software Architecture and Design » Should Software ever be Re-Written?
Photograph of columns in old building

Should software ever be re-written?

Technology is always changing, new versions of development tools, databases, third party components continually appear. In fact about ten years ago somebody said it was a full time job just to keep up with the new tools coming out of Microsoft. If anything in recent years, especially with the advent of Windows Azure, this situation has got worse. So surely, software is obsolete the minute it is written, obviously we should re-write software that we develop every two or three years, right?

Some companies that I have worked for over the years have exactly this strategy. I feel though, in my experience at least, that this was politically driven. There are many good reasons not to redevelop software.

  • If it isn’t broke, why spend a fortune redeveloping it just to say develop in Angular or Kendo UI when plain old webforms will do? Again this re-development will be obsolete as soon as (or before) it is finished
  • The business can spend its money on other business benefits, such as add on modules that provide further benefits
  • There are also better things for developers to do as well than re-write old systems

Against this, you may have to re-write if say the platform (operating system, database etc) becomes obsolete. Or if the software no longer meets business needs. If the software becomes impossible to maintain due to its age and number of changes that have been made to it.

My advice to customers is that if you make careful decisions regarding platform, and go for industry standards such as Microsoft .NET, SQL/Server, Oracle etc., then in this day and age, especially with all the open source code, jQuery, etc., there is no reason not to have software that lasts for decades. The key as a developer, is to keep it easy to maintain, so its easy to change. One way to do this is always to leave code in a better condition than you started with it. The business on the other hand has to give you enough time to be able to do this.

The way I look at software is that above all else, the software is a detailed design specification. It must show the programmers intent, i.e. the detailed requirements of the business, when reading the code. Code must be well organised and super readable. This is harder the more people in the team, particularly if they are geographically separated and work for different companies. But it is possible. There are a number of things that can help.

  • Domain Driven Design
  • SOLID Principles
  • Agile Methodologies
  • TDD
  • Patterns and Practices
  • Object Orientated Design
  • Good Database Design

Obviously not all are needed in the same project. Only you can decide what is appropriate for your requirements.

In the coming months though, this blog will try to examine the above and more with lots of examples. Please be sure to send me feedback and let me know what you think.

About Phil

I have been working as a software developer since 1983. This blog could have been called "From Fortran 77, C and Cobol to C# in 20 (not so) easy years", but it doesn't sound quite right somehow. Besides I'm talking about what's happened since 2003, not before!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Top Posts & Pages


Recent Posts

Recent Comments



  • Mike Cohn's Blog
  • Scott Hanselman's Blog
Be a Great Product Owner: Six Things Teams and Scrum Masters Need

Learn six ways effective product owners ensure their teams’ success. [...]

What Happens When During a Sprint

Succeeding with Scrum is easier when you know when and why to conduct each of the Scrum events during the sprint. [...]

What Are Agile Story Points?

Story points are perhaps the most misunderstood topic in agile. Story points are not based on just one factor--such as complexity, as is often mistakenly claimed. Instead, story points are based on a combination of factors. [...]

Don’t Equate Story Points to Hours

I’ve been quite adamant lately that story points are about time, specifically effort. But that does not mean you should say something like, “One story point = eight hours.” Doing this obviates the main reason to use story points in the... [...]

Epics, Features and User Stories

I've been getting more and more emails lately from people confused about the difference between "user stories", "epics" and "features." So I thought this month we'd return and cover some basic--but very helpful--territory by explaining those terms. First, the terms don't matter that much. These are not terms with important specific meanings like "pointer" to a programmer or "collateralized debt obligation" to whomever it is that's important. [...]

- Scott Hanselman
Use your own user @ domain for Mastodon discoverability with the WebFinger Protocol without hosting a server

Mastodon is a free, open-source social networking service that is decentralized and distributed. It was created in 2016 as an alternative to centralized social media platforms such as Twitter and Facebook. One of the key features of Mastodon is the use of the WebFinger protocol, which allows users to discover and access information about other users on the Mastodon network. WebFinger is a simple HTTP-based protocol that enables a user to discover information about other users or resources on the internet by using their email address or other identifying information. The WebFinger protocol is important for Mastodon because it enables… [...]

- Scott Hanselman
I got tired

I have been blogging here for the last 20 years. Every Tuesday and Thursday, quite consistently, for two decades. But last year, without planning it, I got tired and stopped. Not sure why. It didn't correspond with any life events. Nothing interesting or notable happened. I just stopped. I did find joy on TikTok and amassed a small group of like-minded followers there. I enjoy my YouTube as well, and my weekly podcast is going strong with nearly 900 (!) episodes of interviews with cool people. I've also recently started posting on Mastodon (a fediverse (federated universe)) Twitter alternative that… [...]

- Scott Hanselman
Using Home Assistant to integrate a Unifi Protect G4 Doorbell and Amazon Alexa to announce visitors

I am not a Home Assistant expert, but it's clearly a massive and powerful ecosystem. I've interviewed the creator of Home Assistant on my podcast and I encourage you to check out that chat. Home Assistant can quickly become a hobby that overwhelms you. Every object (entity) in your house that is even remotely connected can become programmable. Everything. Even people! You can declare that any name:value pair that (for example) your phone can expose can be consumable by Home Assistant. Questions like "is Scott home" or "what's Scott's phone battery" can be associated with Scott the Entity in the… [...]

- Scott Hanselman
JavaScript and TypeScript Projects with React, Angular, or Vue in Visual Studio 2022 with or without .NET

I was reading Gabby's blog post about the new TypeScript/JavaScript project experience in Visual Studio 2022. You should read the docs on JavaScript and TypeScript in Visual Studio 2022. If you're used to ASP.NET apps when you think about apps that are JavaScript heavy, "front end apps" or TypeScript focused, it can be confusing as to "where does .NET fit in?" You need to consider the responsibilities of your various projects or subsystems and the multiple totally valid ways you can build a web site or web app. Let's consider just a few: An ASP.NET Web app that renders HTML… [...]

- Scott Hanselman
A Nightscout Segment for OhMyPosh shows my realtime Blood Sugar readings in my Git Prompt

I've talked about how I love a nice pretty prompt in my Windows Terminal and made videos showing in detail how to do it. I've also worked with my buddy TooTallNate to put my real-time blood sugar into a bash or PowerShell prompt, but this was back in 2017. Now that I'm "Team OhMyPosh" I have been meaning to write a Nightscout "segment" for my prompt. Nightscout is an open source self-hosted (there are commercial hosts also like T1Pal) website and API for remote display of real-time and near-real-time glucose readings for Diabetics like myself. Since my body has an… [...]